Licensed Insurance Sales Agent/ Staff Producer

$40K - $100K

per year

Job Description

About the Role

Mike McClaskie - State Farm Agency is hiring a Licensed Insurance Sales Agent/ Staff Producer in Hilliard, OH for a full-time, in-office position focused on helping customers protect what matters most while supporting agency growth. This is an opportunity for a motivated insurance professional who enjoys having meaningful conversations, solving customer needs, and contributing to a team environment where strong performance is recognized.

As a Licensed Insurance Sales Agent/ Staff Producer with Mike McClaskie - State Farm Agency in Hilliard, Ohio, you will work in a fast-paced sales setting where relationship building, product knowledge, and dependable follow-through all matter. The role is a strong fit for someone who already understands the insurance industry, holds an active Property and Casualty license, and wants a position with income potential, professional development, and room to grow within the office.

A Day in the Life

A typical day as a Licensed Insurance Sales Agent/ Staff Producer in Hilliard, OH may include reaching out to new prospects, scheduling appointments, reviewing customer needs, and recommending coverage options that align with each person’s situation. You may spend part of the day answering questions about policies, helping customers with billing or service requests, and following up on leads or prior conversations to keep the sales pipeline active. Because this is an in-office role, much of your success will come from being available, organized, and responsive throughout the day. You will also be expected to communicate clearly, manage multiple priorities, and deliver the kind of friendly, accurate service that builds trust and supports long-term customer relationships.

Key Responsibilities

  • Develop and nurture leads through value-based conversations that identify customer needs and uncover opportunities for coverage.
  • Schedule appointments with prospects and existing customers to review policies, discuss options, and advance sales conversations.
  • Recommend insurance products and services that fit the customer’s goals, household needs, and budget considerations.
  • Build strong customer relationships through consistent follow-up, thoughtful communication, and dependable service.
  • Provide prompt, accurate, and friendly support for routine service requests and policy-related questions.
  • Assist with inquiries involving insurance availability, eligibility, coverages, policy updates, transfers, claims-related questions, and billing clarification.
  • Maintain a steady focus on sales goals, customer retention, and overall office performance.
  • Use your insurance knowledge and communication skills to guide customers through decisions with confidence and clarity.
  • Work collaboratively within the office to support agency priorities and contribute to a positive team culture.
  • Stay organized while managing multiple customer interactions, follow-ups, and administrative tasks in a fast-paced environment.

Required Qualifications

  • Active Property and Casualty insurance license, or the ability to obtain and maintain the required licensing.
  • Ability to commute to the agency location in Hilliard, OH for an in-office work arrangement.
  • Experience in insurance sales or a closely related customer-facing sales role is strongly preferred.
  • Strong verbal, written, and listening skills for effective customer conversations and follow-up.
  • Self-motivated attitude with the ability to work with urgency and manage responsibilities independently.
  • Ability to multitask and stay organized while serving customers and working on sales activities.
  • Comfort with building rapport, asking good questions, and helping customers make informed decisions.
  • Ability to complete any required licensing or training steps associated with the position.

Preferred Skills

  • Prior experience in insurance sales, account management, or customer service within a performance-driven environment.
  • Life and Health insurance licensing, or the ability to obtain it, is a plus.
  • Background in inside sales, outside sales, retail sales, or telemarketing with a proven ability to meet goals.
  • Confidence discussing coverage options in a clear, approachable, and customer-friendly way.
  • Ability to follow a structured process while still adapting to different customer needs.
  • Professional phone presence and strong follow-up habits that support lead conversion and retention.

Pay and Benefits

The compensation range for this Licensed Insurance Sales Agent/ Staff Producer position in Hilliard, OH is $40,000 to $100,000, with earnings structured as a base salary plus commission and bonus opportunities. That means the role can reward both consistent production and strong customer service, offering income potential that grows with performance and results. Mike McClaskie - State Farm Agency also provides a work environment built around support, development, and the chance to gain valuable experience in a respected sales setting.

  • Base salary plus commission/bonus potential
  • Paid time off, including vacation and personal/sick days
  • Valuable experience in the insurance sales field
  • Opportunity for growth and advancement within the office
  • Full-time, in-office role with a stable weekday work structure

Career Growth

This Licensed Insurance Sales Agent/ Staff Producer role can be an excellent step for someone who wants to build a long-term career in insurance sales. For the right person, it can lead to stronger production responsibilities, deeper account management work, and expanded opportunities within the agency. As you develop more expertise in customer conversations, policy recommendations, and lead conversion, you may become a key contributor to the office’s growth and a trusted resource for both new and existing customers. Over time, this experience can also support advancement into more senior sales, service, or agency-related roles.

Working in Hilliard, OH

Hilliard, OH is part of the greater Columbus area and offers a strong setting for insurance sales professionals who want to serve a diverse mix of households and small businesses. The local market includes established neighborhoods, growing commercial areas, and a steady flow of residents who often value dependable insurance guidance and personalized service. For professionals seeking Licensed Insurance Sales Agent jobs in Hilliard, OH, this location combines suburban convenience with access to a broader regional economy. Commuting is generally manageable for those living in western Columbus communities and surrounding suburbs, and the area offers a practical balance of work, errands, and day-to-day convenience.

Why Join Mike McClaskie - State Farm Agency

Mike McClaskie - State Farm Agency offers an environment centered on helping customers, supporting team success, and creating meaningful opportunities for growth. If you enjoy the challenge of a sales role but also want to provide genuine service, this position gives you both. The agency’s focus on value-based conversations means you can rely on your communication skills and insurance knowledge to make a real difference for customers while also working toward your own professional goals. For a Licensed Insurance Sales Agent/ Staff Producer in Hilliard, OH, that combination of purpose, performance, and income potential can be especially appealing.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is this Licensed Insurance Sales Agent/ Staff Producer position in-office?

Yes. This role is an in-office position in Hilliard, OH, and candidates must be able to commute to the agency location. The job is designed for someone who can work closely with the team and be available for daily customer and sales activities.

Do I need an active insurance license to apply?

An active Property and Casualty insurance license is required to be considered for the role. Life and Health licensing is also preferred, and candidates should be able to obtain any additional licenses needed for the position.

What kind of experience helps someone succeed in this job?

Insurance sales experience is highly relevant, but other sales backgrounds can also help. Experience in inside sales, outside sales, retail sales, or telemarketing may be useful, especially if you have a track record of meeting goals and building customer relationships.

What does success look like in this role?

Success means developing leads, scheduling effective appointments, matching customers with appropriate coverage, and delivering reliable service that encourages trust and retention. Strong communication, organization, and follow-through are key parts of performing well in this role.

How to Apply

If you are ready to take the next step in your insurance career and can see yourself succeeding as a Licensed Insurance Sales Agent/ Staff Producer in Hilliard, OH, submit your resume through this listing. Qualified applicants will be contacted with the next steps in the interview process.

Apply for Licensed Insurance Sales Agent/ Staff Producer

Submit your application for this position at Mike McClaskie - State Farm Agency

When you apply, we automatically create a free candidate account for your email address so every application is saved in one place. Choose a password (8 characters or more) to sign in straight away — or set one later from the link in your confirmation email. You can delete your account at any time from your account page.

PDF, DOC, or DOCX (max 5MB)

Ready to Apply?

Submit your application for this position